If you yourself believe the movie to be bad then you're right, but everyone else is not wrong.But saying that, it also can be important to figure out the reasons other people have different opinions on something, no interpretation of a text is final and exploring how others have interpreted something differently can open up a new way for you to view the text.This is how I feel about The Shawshank Redemption: It may be overproduced, sentimental Hollywood schlock, but as far as such things go, it is absolutely top notch grade-A Hollywood schlock.
It's a timeless lesson; a parable, told via film.Since this sub is geared more toward active discussion of film, can you please outline what you didn't like about the film? The beer break on the roof, the opera played over the PA, and finally the broken boat on the shores of the Pacific: each of these moments is engineered by Andy to get a taste, a glimpse of freedom.
The Shawshank Redemption is a powerful film on every level, but seriously overrated. You won't study it in a film class.
It is balanced, the tension is sustained, it's engaging, it has funny witty lines and tearjerker moments.
It creates memorable characters, has interesting scenes, a compelling central conflict, a well paced plot, and a satisfying ending. It really is a remarkable example of underacting, and it's the one thing about the movie that feels truly, vitally There's nothing bold or experimental about it; it's not gritty or rawI think this is my favorite fact about the film.
It appeals to wide demographics, particularly men.
Which is not to say disregard others opinions but accept that others might be wrong.Which is not to say disregard others opinions but accept that others might be wrong.When we evaluate film, or any art for that matter, how are we evaluating it? Anyways It's great because you don't see it coming.
Wading through a reddish desert sand, she climbs the stairs to find a large projection room where she sees an “echo” image of five pillars surrounded by amber sand — evidence that the object of power was once used in the room to contact what is believed to be Polaris, the dimensional being traveling in … Shawshank isn't the best movie ever made, but it might be the best "good" movie ever made.
What it is is just a terrifically entertaining film with tremendous acting (Morgan Freeman at his best) and a beautiful story.
For instance, a shot which doesn't call attention to itself by subverting expectations but instead moves in a way that matches the mood of the scene (for instance, a slow push-in on two characters as their conversation becomes more intimate) is just as valid as something "gritty" or "experimental". And if you've wandered into this thread and haven't seen the film, go and watch it right now I promise you it's such an awesome film.
It's a fantasy story really. Both end up together on a beach in Mexico, to live out the rest of their lives in solitude, apart from society. Don't let it stop you The Shawshank Redemption is a powerful film on every level, but seriously overrated. I like how Darabont stayed faithful to King's ambiguous ending in a sense by having the camera leave the two friends in the distance, while still making it a heartfelt and emotional reunion onscreen.
There have been several For me, his struggle has been a metaphor for different things. I realise that strategy is better than hope.Andy Dufresne represents people who believe they are trapped in jobs, relationships, families, locations, turmoil, vices, addictions, debt, depression, and shows how escape can (and If you notice, so far I haven't touched upon the technical execution of the story. Rating 2256173 Vote Movie info Chronicles the experiences of a formerly successful banker as a prisoner in the gloomy jailhouse of Shawshank after being found guilty of a crime he did not commit. That's why, fortunately, art is always up to interpretation.You're the first person I know who doesn't like Shawshank. ", because it's a great movie.
Another thing that makes the ending powerful is that from the moment Andy enters the prison you feel for him, you want him to succeed and you don't want him to suffer the attacks from the sisters.
If you made a graph of quality films, and on top of it a graph of popular films, Shawshank would be right where the two lines meet. We all at sometime imagine what it'd be like if we had to go to prison, and most likely a guy like me wouldn't do to well. I think a lot people feel trapped in some way, with occasional feelings of freedom, and so respond to what feels emotionally real. Shawshank draws its strength from our attitudes towards prison and prisoners, but it then betrays the truth of its setting by setting up a falsely optimistic worldview where none of the characters are really guilty and their only task is to fight against an undeserved oppression. Did he kill his wife? Any film can have a happy ending, but only a masterful one can truly emotionally invest you in it. The shawshank redemption ending scene.
The shawshank redemption best scene.
And when we talk amongst ourselves about a piece what are we trying to do? It appeals to wide demographics, particularly men.
It presents itself well-formed, fully dressed, and without a lot of accessory effects.Darabont's commentary on Shawshank goes over a lot of technical choices he made specifically for their narrative effect.
It is a fun wholesome film with a feel good ending.
It's a great ending because it earns it. That's always felt like the tragedy of Shawshank; criminal or not, everyone ends up the same broken man by the end.The brief moments of freedom in this film shine like nothing else, for me. So can somebody justify this for me please?EDIT: Thanks so much for all the responses :) so, I guess the consensus is that it's good because it simply has nothing anyone could really gripe about? King and Darabont are both born storytellers, and Robbins and Freeman are charming, sympathetic leads. If not (or if you've already seen it) try watching Shawshank again and pay close attention to Tim Robbins's performance.
I don't think you can easily separate technical skill and narrative skill. It's hard to make honest films that are also just a good time. Like it's bizarre how quick It's a great ending because it earns it.